Does the final shape of REF 2029 answer its culture critics?
Is that it, then? Now that the 2029 REF guidance is locked down, will the university sector move on from debating the format of the people and culture elements, and turn attention to more pressing questions like what the exercise looks like when everyone’s at risk of redundancy?
Well, perhaps not. The culture wars – so to speak – never go away, even if the word gets removed from the overall scoring terminology. But I thought it might be instructive to go back at what was originally proposed, who was most unhappy about it, and where we ended up.
The initial decisions for REF 2028 (as was) proposed a “more tightly defined, questionnaire-style template” for the People, Culture and Environment element (as was). This would “focus on demonstrable outcomes” and “minimise the preparation and assessment burden for HEIs and panels.”
One pilot had proposed that the whole research environment aspect of the REF should be moved in its entirety to the institution-level. This wasn’t taken forward, but it was promised that the institution-level statement would be assessed, rather than simply contextual, and worth “at least 20 per cent” of the overall PCE score.
In the final reckoning, however, there will be 10,000 word statements for both the institution and the unit, and the former will be worth 60 per cent.
One of the important interventions in the interim came from former Warwick vice chancellor Nigel Thrift, who called the planned PCE element an “amorphous entity” and warned that reliance on narratives appeared to be a “particularly unreliable means of judging things.”
Those who wanted outputs to be more prominent essentially got their way, following Patrick Vallance’s intervention, with the Contributions to Knowledge and Understanding percentage bumped up and the narrative part of that element removed.
But as for the “amorphousness” – well, we’ve ended up quite a long way from a tight questionnaire-style approach with specific indicators. Rather, those compiling the long SPRE submissions have an enormous platter of different metrics to select between, from contract types to staff experience, from success rates in funding applications to data on bullying and harassment. It’s hard to get a feel for how panels will respond, I would suggest – the temptation for those compiling statements surely must be to try and cram in as much as possible.
The quest to identify and specify particular indicators for PCE was of course one of the other hotly contested areas of REF development. Here there are many different interventions we could look back on, but I always felt that the Office for Students submission to the REF, from free speech director Arif Ahmed, was one of the more interesting ones.
Ahmed pointed out that the regulator’s new free speech rules (England-only) may require institutions “not to adopt charters or seek accreditations” in some circumstances:
“This may happen, for instance, where a charter or accreditation body requires that a university adopts a position on sex and gender, or on race, that chills or obstructs lawful but controversial research into those subjects.”
On the opportunity side, he felt that there was a “strong case” to include some prominent reference to academic freedom within the research environment assessment section, reflecting the extent to which a unit “supports and promotes freedom for all staff and research students to question and test received wisdom.”
The final guidance certainly doesn’t mandate signing up to any concordat or charter. Nor does it rule it out – one possible indicator in the strategy section of SPRE is evidence related to charter/concordats principles (of which there are many to pick from). As we’ve seen, there are so many metrics on offer that everyone is rather spoiled for choice, and essentially none can be said to be required.
This is not to say, however, that academic freedom made the cut as a suggested indicator – Ahmed’s suggestion doesn’t seem to have been taken onboard there. Still, institutions and units will be free to include it should they so wish, as the one thing we’ve ended up with is almost limitless flexibility. The issue with this is that it becomes hard to know where to start, let alone how to assess.
Despite the rollback on culture that emerged from the 2025 pause, those who spent much of the first half of the current window criticising its inclusion and/or format didn’t get everything they wanted. Of course not – who did? But beyond that, in getting some of what they wanted they ended up with more of certain things they actively did not. And if that’s not in the spirit of the 2029 REF, I don’t know what is.
Spotted a politician meddling in the research system? Or a blurry line between academia and government? Email the man himself: haldane [at] researchagenda [dot] news