About Research Agenda The news service for UK research – original reporting, analysis and email briefings, from the team behind Wonkhe. A practice of Thesis. About us → Subscribe Free while we build Register free for everything through the founding period. Founding subscriptions are open now: Individuals · independents and small practices Institutions · organisation-wide access Funders & corporates · scoped to your organisation How subscriptions work → Register – free
Research Agenda. The archive →

News · Europe and international

The UK can’t afford full membership of the next Horizon Europe, think tank argues


Science policy organisation Science Works is releasing modelling today which, it argues, shows that full participation in the 2028–34 Horizon programme would “blow a hole” in the UK’s science budgets.

This is because – as recently explored on Research Agenda – the 2025 spending review only made provision for a UK contribution to EU research programmes at roughly the same level as now, saying that the allocation would be reviewed once more information was known.

Science Works’ analysis, from former DSIT advisor Ben Johnson and former Treasury advisor Will Stone, proposes that the expanded Horizon programme which is likely to emerge from ongoing EU negotiations will create a gap of £1.2bn in the government’s spending plans by 2029–30, which will have to made up from elsewhere.

The authors conclude that the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade’s R&D budget would take a substantial hit from full association, potentially leaving it with 20 per cent less to spend elsewhere. They argue that such a scenario would make it also much harder for the government to “guide the UK research base towards the UK’s own strategic interests.”

Their analysis also questions whether full association is desirable, and argues that whatever the final decision, funding to pay for Horizon Europe needs to be earmarked as soon as possible. The longer the government takes to decide, the authors suggest, the more likely that it will have to impose cuts in areas such as university block grants.

The central scenario in Science Works modelling is based on the €158bn proposal (in current prices) which the Irish EU presidency proposed in October, currently being haggled over by member states. Both MEPs and European research groups are pushing for the overall Horizon envelope to rise, towards the €200bn target which Mario Draghi called for in his report on European competitiveness.

Johnson and Stone see little possibility that the UK would decline entirely to associate to the next Horizon, observing that such a move would be “diametrically opposed to the government’s stated goal of closer relationships with the EU” – and forgo the clear benefits on offer. Instead, they make the case that Westminster should aim to associate only to FP10’s Excellent Science pillar:

“This option is much cheaper than full association, releasing more money for investment in UK domestic programmes that could better meet the UK’s own strategic and economic priorities [...] This is an ambitious position, but not an impossible one, and to write it off in advance is to neglect the UK’s best interests.”

Pillar one includes the European Research Council and the Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions where UK researchers have performed strongly since reassociation was agreed in 2023. The UK is also participating in the current pillar two – Global Challenges and European Industrial Competitiveness – and part of pillar three, Innovative Europe. To date its success rates in these areas have been somewhat lower.

The next framework programme, as currently proposed, will have four pillars in a structure similar to the current set-up but with an additional European Research Area pillar. While the UK could seek partial association, it appears unlikely that the EU would allow for participation in the Excellent Science strand alone. Other large economies which have partially associated to the current Horizon Europe – Canada, South Korea, Japan, and New Zealand, for example – are all participating in pillar two only.

The authors do note, however, that there is one precedent: Switzerland was briefly associated to pillar one alone in the mid-2010s. 

Research Agenda is free through the founding period

We’re building this in the open – be part of it

Sign up for the briefing and stay in the loop as Research Agenda comes to life – free through the founding period.