The Migration Advisory Committee reviews the global talent visa
The Home Office’s independent advisory committee decided to launch a review of the UK’s visa routes for attracting international “talent” earlier this year. As we saw earlier this month, the government’s earned settlement reforms were subsequently tied together with the findings of this review – meaning that for those holding global talent visas wanting to stay long-term in the UK, the committee’s recommendations took on additional importance.
The Migration Advisory Committee (MAC) has now given the global talent visa a largely clean bill of health, saying that the route’s labour market outcomes are “largely acceptable”, though it does make some recommendations for tightening up aspects of the process by which applicants are endorsed. The other visa route it has reviewed – the Innovator Founder route, used for those planning to start a business – does not come across so well, with MAC recommending its abolition (or at least complete overhaul).
For the review, the MAC secretariat and members spoke to all endorsing bodies for the two routes. It also received access to relevant internal Home Office data, allowing for some additional insight into who holds the visas, who has endorsed them, and what fields they go on to work in.
Global talent
As the committee notes, the global talent visa is “primarily used by academics” and those working in the UK research system. For these applicants, there are four routes to acquire a visa:
- academic and research appointments (fast-track): individuals who have accepted an eligible position at an approved UK higher education institute or research institute
- individual fellowships (fast-track): for those awarded an individual fellowship on a list approved by the British Academy, Royal Academy of Engineering and the Royal Society
- endorsed funders: applicants whose name or job title is specified in a successful grant application from an endorsed funder. The endorsed funder list is maintained by UKRI, and has recently been expanded, with a further opening-up promised in the Budget
- the peer review pathway: an endorsement process through which applicants can be individually assessed on their talent by the British Academy, Royal Academy of Engineering or the Royal Society.
There are also routes for arts and culture, and digital technology, with separate endorsing organisations. The latest overall data on application numbers can be found in this Research Agenda article – they have held relatively steady over the last few years, after scaling up quickly following the route’s introduction in 2020. The MAC’s review includes some further information which was not previously in the public domain, such as the number of endorsements per endorsing body:
The committee also notes that the global talent visa appears to be becoming “more concentrated among a smaller number of nationalities,” primarily China and the USA.
MAC’s analysis of the route’s merit is twofold: exploring salary and employment data for those holding global talent visas, and assessing the endorsement process. For the former, it finds that the employment rate is high and earnings are “respectable, if not stellar” – in large part, the committee observes, this is because a majority are working in academia where remuneration is worse:
Overall, MAC estimates that main applicants in the global talent scheme make a fiscal contribution of around £400,000 per person (£260,000 for those in higher education).
What the committee wasn’t able to unpick was how salary and employment outcomes varied by endorsing body – it recommends the Home Office improve its record-keeping so that fuller analysis is possible, to better shed light on which parts of the global talent route are “having the most significant economic and fiscal contributions.”
The endorsement process
From speaking to the endorsing bodies involved with the global talent visa, one issue which MAC flags is an increase in “poor-quality applications” (on the standard track – the fast track routes are extremely robust given that they require a job or fellowship to have been obtained).
“These include completely unsuitable applications as well as some that are considered slightly premature, with the applicant likely to qualify for endorsement once they have gained more experience. An increase in AI-generated applications was also reported, as were some fraudulent applications.”
This is in the context of a rising number of applications, and a falling endorsement rate:
Predictably, this means that those organisations involved with endorsements are finding themselves obliged to dedicate more assessor time to processing applications. MAC suggests that this is clearly “creating strain on the system,” but for the academic side of the route stops short of recommending much change. It suggests that the Home Office work with endorsing bodies to “consider how the number of applications that go through the peer review route could be reduced through raising the bar for a full review.”
As the committee ran a call for evidence earlier this year, it has received many suggestions on how the global talent route could be expanded – for example, to include more research-related roles – and today’s report summarises many of them. For example, stakeholders raised the issue of the challenges faced by early-career applicants, such as those approaching the end of their careers.
MAC largely judges these issues and recommendations as out of its scope, concluding that exactly who can access the route is more a matter for the government, or at least would need a more detailed, occupation-specific review. But it adds that eligibility requirements should not be “diluted” significantly.
The committee does recommend “tightening” aspects of the application process to increase its robustness (and indeed the BBC has recently highlighted apparent fraud in non-academic parts of the route).
When endorsing bodies assess applications – again, on the non-fast-track parts of the scheme – they will use various indicators to judge candidates’ suitability. For academics, this might include journal articles or awards, but MAC heard that letters of recommendation were “particularly important in evidencing talent.”
The current process, by which applicants collect letters from referees and then submit them to endorsing organisations, is found to create “opportunities for fabrication or unauthorised editing,” as well as potentially influencing what referees write. MAC calls for references to be submitted directly and confidentially to endorsing bodies, a move which would tighten up the process but also generate additional bureaucracy.
Settlement
Given how the committee’s review has become bound up with the Home Office’s earned settlement plans, the proposals on settlement requirements are likely to attract attention. The plan had been for those on global talent routes to be eligible for earned settlement after three years.
MAC notes that a “non-trivial share” of those on the route “appear to have extremely low earnings.” It therefore calls for settlement applicants to meet an income threshold, based on the minimum wage. But it recommends against any system whereby global talent visaholders’ “contribution” to the UK is assessed upon applying for settlement; rather, it wants to see a “light-touch” Home Office assessment to provide “confidence the applicant had been working in the field of endorsement, without onerous documentary requirements.” And – unlike for the innovation founder visa – the three-year wait is judged to be appropriate.
The exact technical details of how the earned settlement proposals will work, as well as the dates from which changes will be made, remain to be seen pending the laying of parliamentary regulations, expected in December.
Visa fees
The high visa fees and Immigration Health Surcharge faced by those on global talent visas (and other immigration routes) is a long-standing object of criticism from the research sector. It’s no surprise, then, to see that the MAC’s call for evidence saw this highlighted “extensively” by respondents – and endorsing bodies made the same argument. High fees and additional NHS charges, the committee was told, are deterring talented applicants:
“We were told that in some cases, migrants may get to the point of making their application and receiving endorsement, before finding out about the fees they need to pay [...] Stakeholders, including among endorsing bodies, universities and research institutes, said that even if high fees do not deter migrants from coming to the UK entirely, they may still reduce retention.”
MAC concludes that it does not have the evidence it would require to consider the matter properly. It is happy to admit that upfront costs are more likely to be a barrier to those from less wealthy countries, to those paying multiple years in advance, and in less well-remunerated sectors such as academia.
“However, we cannot quantify the scale of this effect, and it is possible that it is relatively small given that most people on talent routes have relatively comfortable salaries. If fees affect retention on the visa, the scale of this is not likely to be very large, given the high share of those not on the visa who progress to settlement.”
The only recommendation it makes is that the Home Office review uptake of the global talent visa once the government’s announced fee reimbursement has been properly rolled out. This reimbursement was announced in June, and applies to those working at scale-up companies in digital and tech, life sciences, and clean energy.
MAC suggests that the performance of this limited initiative can give further insight about whether applicants are genuinely being deterred: “if increased uptake is seen, and the benefits from that outweigh costs, it may indicate it would be sensible to extend this fee policy further.” Beyond that, the many representations over high visa fees and the NHS surcharge go unheeded.
Innovators and investors
While the global talent visa gets a qualified pass from MAC, the same cannot be said for the innovator founder visa, which requires applicants to get business plans endorsed by one of four organisations. The purpose of the route, the committee notes, is to “attract migrants with innovative, viable and scalable business ideas” to establish and grow their businesses in the UK.
The route is criticised from all angles: applicants and advisors are said to find it difficult to manage, the Home Office reportedly has concerns about robustness, and – based on salary and employment data – the committee finds that the median visaholder’s business is not generating much income, and not employing many additional staff:
“Selecting successful entrepreneurs is inherently difficult. Many businesses fail, many others subsist without being particularly successful, and it is not always possible to know which will flourish. Entrepreneur visas will always struggle with this challenge to some extent. In our view, the Innovator Founder visa has not cracked the problem.”
The committee concludes that it could simply be abolished, though wonders whether the higher-performing parts of the route can be “salvaged” – a deeper review would be needed for this. As for earned settlement, MAC argues that the time requirement should be five years, rather than three, and there should be a similar personal income requirement as with the global talent visa.
MAC also addresses calls for the UK to reintroduce some form of investor visa, or append provisions for those investing large amounts to the existing talent visas. Various respondents to its call for evidence pushed for this, and recent media reports suggest that it was under active consideration by the government over the last year. The committee is not persuaded by the arguments made, and recommends against any new route for investors.