Report explores “misunderstandings” about the meaning of innovation
Innovation is one of those terms that we all instinctively think we know. It is the process of conjuring the new from the base materials of the old. The army crawl through the mud of bad ideas to as yet undiscovered sunny uplands. Or, as the OECD puts in its widely cited manual:
“An innovation is a new or improved product or process (or combination thereof) that differs significantly from the unit’s previous products or processes and that has been made available to potential users (product) or brought into use by the unit (process).”
It turns out that the way in which innovation is defined has a real world impact, and that the use of the term differs between people and places. It is not merely a linguistic game but a genuine barrier to collaboration between partners.
The Local Policy Innovation Partnership Hub has a new report out exploring just this topic: the languages of innovation and economic development policies at subnational level in the uk. The central argument of the report is that universities, combined authorities, UKRI, and central government all use the term innovation differently, leading to “misunderstandings and policy misalignment.” What appears to be agreement, the report concludes, can often mask “fundamentally different assumptions about goals and outcomes.”
The consequence of this is that combined authorities and other regional actors hold a disproportionate amount of responsibility for working between different definitions. To take only one practical example, there can be a disconnect when local partners think of innovation funding as about economic development while funders are thinking of commercialisation and novelty.
It is not even that there is a definitional problem on its own terms but that this definitional challenge rarely surfaced. The consequence is that aims are diffuse when a project moves from idea to delivery. As the report puts it:
“Because these distinctions are rarely made explicit, different parts of the innovation ‘helix’ can use the same language while working to different assumptions – generating tension in funding design, bidding, and programme delivery.”
It is also worth remarking that the differences in definition do end up serving a “useful” purpose: they allow different players to believe they are all working for similar goals when in reality they may have differences between them. Of course, the solution to this is not simply agreeing on a better definition, but rather reshaping the innovation landscape to allow for greater coordinating capacity:
“There are policy levers that could connect national and subnational innovation policy much better, but they point toward a more activist, place-based industrial innovation policy rather than simply better coordination. The strongest package would combine statutory local innovation strategies, flexible multi-year settlements, stronger regional innovation governance, a broader policy mix including procurement and experimentation, explicit support for diffusion and adoption, and investment in subnational policy capability.”
In a multi-actor innovation landscape the need for translation becomes more acute. Sometimes, that will be the coordination of shared ideas to arrive at the same outcomes. Sometimes, it will be a significant investment to build capacity across the whole ecosystem.