Science committee continues its scrutiny of STFC decisions
The House of Commons Science and Technology Committee has held a follow-up hearing exploring the impact on UK science from changes to Science and Technology Facilities Council (STFC) spending. MPs took evidence from a similar panel of guests to that which gave evidence in the spring.
Committee chair Chi Onwurah noted that invites had been extended to representatives of STFC’s three multidisciplinary facilities, who had been unable to attend on this occasion. Lib Dem MP Freddie van Mierlo later suggested that the facilities staff had been “gagged by UKRI and by the Labour government” – Onwurah was quick to clarify that this was not the impression she had been given.
Several themes loomed large in the discussion: first and foremost was the question of transparency, and whether STFC’s prioritisation process had been clearly communicated to those affected. Jon Butterworth, a physics professor at UCL involved with CERN’s Atlas programme, argued that the council had published the results of the process, but not the underlying reasoning: “the outcomes are there, but the rationale is not actually public.”
Scotland’s Astronomer Royal Catherine Heymans added that some of the differences between the content of ministerial statements, and what was being experienced on the ground, were “very concerning.”
Other issues which witnesses gave evidence to the committee on included the “brain drain” of physics postdocs leaving the UK, whether applicant-led research was genuinely being protected in UKRI’s spending plans – University of Cambridge professor George Efstathio proposed that the bucket approach to allocations was a means to “obfuscate” about the true situation – and the extent to which the UK’s international reputation had been damaged by withdrawal from certain commitments.
The meeting can be replayed on the committee’s events page, where a transcript will appear later this week.
The subject of STFC cuts also came up in a Foundation for Science and Technology interview last week with Patrick Vallance. The former science minister said that the council had received an essentially flat budget, which was “a lot better than almost every other department got,” and that there had been a need to “contain” costs given the funding council’s “history of overspend which was eating into lots of other research councils.”
A subsequent audience question saw Vallance asked who had taken the policy decision to remove the so-called Drayson partitions between research spending and spending on facilities, infrastructure and subscriptions. The former minister, now chair of the government’s AI taskforce, replied that the partitions had never been “a thing you could point at,” and that UKRI was still following the broader concept behind them, namely protecting curiosity-driven research.